It's not working. I'm okay with that.
The pattern showed three dimensional texture. I cast on and knit three or four rows. Using sport weight alpaca yarn to substitute for worsted weight cashmere was the deal killer.
I voiced my doubts to Mr. E. We decided that knitting one repeat of the pattern (16 rows) would be enough to see what the yarn and pattern would produce.
There is not enough textural stiffness to the alpaca to make the definition of form required by those inward pockets. The weight and drapiness of the scarf will stretch the pockets even more. The scarf will then look like simple lace.
I bailed before he did. He understood and agreed.
Last night, we walked to a restaurant near the hospital. Our path took us around buildings, and then into the teeth of the storm. Dinner in town would give the commuters time to finish their version of Boston bumpercars without our participation. We would head home later on empty streets. The plan worked well.
As we walked into the wind, snow blowing through my teeth, I turned to the DH. "It is now that I truly appreciate the value of handknits." I was wrapped in two scarves (Irish Hiking, and a commercial cashmere), a hat knit of angora by my mom over 15 years ago. My hands were covered by alpaca mittens knit by someone vending at Rhinebeck 2007.
I'm working on a new fashion look. It is two complementary (or not) scarves worn together. You can wrap one around your neck and let the other hang in front. Or you can wrap both. Or you can wrap neither. It is a versatile combination, and it is warm when the weather outside is frightful. Let it snow let it snow let it snow!
That is such a pretty pattern, and such a shame the yarn wouldn't work it up right. Dig around in your stash and I know you'll find the correct fiber!
Posted by: Carol Cousins-Tyler | Saturday, December 20, 2008 at 07:05 PM
I'm all for multiple scarves!
Posted by: Kathy | Saturday, December 20, 2008 at 07:35 PM
Did the multiple knits today- a cowl over my turtleneck and a scarf over all that followed by my husband's jacket and a hat. One hand in a commercial mitten the other hidden in the jacket sleeve- with the hand splint ( and an inflexible thumb) it won't fit in a mitten. I was warm though.
Posted by: Manise | Saturday, December 20, 2008 at 10:04 PM
Having spent a substantial amount of time outside yesterday and today, I can appreciate the need for your new fashion look. So get cracking, woman, and find a yarn to do that pattern proud! Your adoring public wants to see it wrapped around your neck.
Posted by: Chris | Saturday, December 20, 2008 at 10:05 PM
*sigh*
Posted by: gayle | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 06:20 AM
Sounds like a good idea to me. The weather outside has indeed been frightful.
Posted by: Carole | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 07:42 AM
Or one big wrap will do the job, too. The difference between a novice and a "real" knitter is knowing when to bail.
Posted by: margene | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 09:02 AM
Wool is more precious than gold or diamonds. Alpaca and cashmere are pretty good, too. So spring for the worsted weight cahmere. Or spin your own - double your pleasure!
Posted by: Lynn | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 12:01 PM
I hope you guys are home today!
Posted by: claudia | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 02:03 PM
The snow out here is so beautiful. We didnt get any wind though. Wind takes a bit of the pleasure out of the white wonderfulness that is snow.
Really like your "layering". Thanks for the fashion suggestion!
And, lastly, any natural fiber, knit into something you love is better than 10 machine made items any day. Too bad the yarn didn't work for your project. I agree with who ever said to spring for the cashmere. You are worth every penny.
Posted by: bev | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 02:51 PM
It was doomed once it had crossed the boundary into lace. It's fine if it's "texture" or maybe even "openwork" but it's a rare husband that will wear lace. Mine will wear socks in any colour whatsoever (maybe not pink) but they can't have a suspicion of an eyelet.
Posted by: Caroline M | Sunday, December 21, 2008 at 06:20 PM
Good to listen to that inner knitting voice that tells you something isn't going to work before you are too invested in it.
Hmm........your new look sounds perfect!
Posted by: Kim | Monday, December 22, 2008 at 08:33 AM
Scarves are in. No, really, they are, one or more at a time. Of course I wear them whether they are or not, but it's nice to be in fashion now and then, stopped-clock-like.
Yeah, alpaca is lovely stuff, but crisp it is not. I found that out when I knit a cabled scarf out of it.
Posted by: Lucia | Monday, December 22, 2008 at 01:38 PM
love the idea of multiple scarves :-) I think that I shall try that myself next time I am out shoveling the driveway (like tonight perhaps)
heh heh holiday 'bumpercars' what a great image. Glad you avoided that.
Posted by: Teyani | Monday, December 22, 2008 at 04:00 PM
I'm all for multiple scarves. I wear one inside my coat. The other is usually a large scarf or even a shawl that gets wrapped around on top of the coat. It can be draped loosely if it's not too cold, but when the wind blows I snug it up and even pull it over my face.
Posted by: technikat | Tuesday, December 23, 2008 at 12:12 PM